HTML Guide

A <source> element inside a <picture> that is followed by another <source> or an <img> with srcset must include a media and/or type attribute.

The <source> element is used inside <picture> for responsive images, allowing different resources to be loaded based on conditions such as viewport width (media) or image format (type). According to the HTML standard, when multiple <source> elements are present (or a following <img> with srcset), each <source> must provide a media and/or type attribute so the browser can choose the appropriate resource based on those hints.

Without media or type, the browser cannot distinguish when to use each source, which can lead to validation errors and unexpected rendering behavior.

Incorrect example (causes the validator error):

<picture>
  <source srcset="image1.webp">
  <source srcset="image2.jpg">
  <img alt="" src="fallback.jpg" srcset="fallback2x.jpg 2x">
</picture>

Correct examples (fixing the error):

<picture>
  <source srcset="image1.webp" type="image/webp">
  <source srcset="image2.jpg" type="image/jpeg">
  <img alt="" src="fallback.jpg" srcset="fallback2x.jpg 2x">
</picture>

or

<picture>
  <source srcset="image-small.jpg" media="(max-width: 600px)">
  <source srcset="image-large.jpg" media="(min-width: 601px)">
  <img alt="" src="fallback.jpg" srcset="fallback2x.jpg 2x">
</picture>

By specifying the media and/or type attributes for each <source>, you satisfy the HTML standard and resolve the W3C validator issue.

The sizes attribute is used to complement the srcset attribute on an <img> tag for responsive images. When this attribute is present, all image candidates must specify its width.

All values in the srcset attribute must include a width descriptor (such as 300w) when the sizes attribute is present.

The srcset attribute is used to provide multiple image sources for responsive images. Each image candidate string in srcset must specify the image’s width (e.g., 600w) or pixel density (e.g., 2x). When you use a sizes attribute, all srcset candidates must use width descriptors (w).

Example of incorrect usage:

<img
  src="/img/pic1.jpg"
  srcset="/img/pic1.jpg"
  sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px"
  alt=""
>

This example is invalid because the srcset value does not include a width descriptor.

Corrected usage with width descriptors:

<img
  src="/img/pic1.jpg"
  srcset="/img/pic1.jpg 600w"
  sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px"
  alt=""
>

If you have multiple image sizes, include each with its corresponding width:

<img
  src="/img/pic1.jpg"
  srcset="
    /img/pic1_small.jpg 300w,
    /img/pic1.jpg 600w
  "
  sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px"
  alt=""
>

Always match each image URL in srcset with a width (w) or pixel density (x) descriptor if appropriate for your layout.

The srcset property on img elements, when used, requires at least one value. This property is a string which identifies one or more image candidate strings, separated using commas (,) each specifying image resources to use under given circumstances.

Each image candidate string contains an image URL and an optional width or pixel density descriptor that indicates the conditions under which that candidate should be used instead of the image specified by the src property.

Example:

<img
    src="/img/cat-200px.png"
    alt="Cat"
    srcset="
      /img/cat-200px.png 1x,
      /img/cat-400px.png 2x
    ">

The srcset attribute requires a width descriptor (w) or pixel density descriptor (x) for each image candidate when the sizes attribute is present.

When using the sizes attribute on an img element, each entry in srcset must include either a width descriptor (e.g., 860w) or a pixel density descriptor (e.g., 2x). This tells browsers how to select the most appropriate image source for the current viewport or display density. Omitting the descriptor leads to HTML validation errors and unexpected image selection.

Correct usage with width descriptors:

<img
  alt=""
  sizes="(min-width:568px) 140px"
  srcset="photo.png?w=860&amp;q=90 860w"
  src="photo.png?w=860&amp;q=90">

Correct usage with pixel density descriptors (if sizes is removed):

<img
  alt=""
  srcset="photo.png?w=860&amp;q=90 2x"
  src="photo.png?w=860&amp;q=90">

Key points:

• With sizes, use width descriptors (e.g., 860w).
• Without sizes, you may use pixel density descriptors (e.g., 2x).
• Always use either px or w units in the sizes attribute values; do not use w.

Ensure all descriptors in the srcset have positive widths greater than zero. In the srcset attribute, each source candidate consists of a URL followed by a width descriptor, which should be a positive integer followed by w.

The issue arises from using 0w, which is not valid as width descriptors must be positive numbers. The srcset attribute allows browsers to choose the appropriate image from different candidates based on device resolution and screen size, so specifying a meaningful width is important.

Here’s how you can fix it:

1. Verify that each candidate in the srcset includes a valid URL and a width descriptor greater than zero.
2. Decide the relevant width for your images and update the descriptors accordingly.

Here’s a corrected example of how to use the srcset attribute:

<picture>
  <source 
    srcset="/images/icon_small_1x.png 300w,
            /images/icon_small_2x.png 600w" 
    media="(max-width: 600px)">
  <img src="/images/icon_fallback.png" 
       alt="App Logo">
</picture>

In this example, each image in srcset has a positive width descriptor: 300w and 600w. This ensures that the browser can make an appropriate choice based on the current viewport and resolution, adhering to the W3C HTML standards.

The sizes attribute is used to complement the srcset attribute on an <img> tag for responsive images. When this attribute is present, all image candidates must specify its width.

The sizes attribute is used to complement the srcset attribute on an <img> tag for responsive images, therefore it’s not valid if srcset is missing.

The W3C validator error you are seeing indicates that you’ve used the sizes attribute on an <img> element without providing a srcset attribute. According to HTML specifications, the sizes attribute is only meaningful when used alongside the srcset attribute.

The srcset attribute allows you to specify a list of possible image files for the browser to choose from based on conditions like the screen size or resolution. The sizes attribute helps the browser understand what size the image should be under specific conditions defined in srcset.

How to Fix the Issue

There are two options, adding or removing attributes.

1. Adding a srcset Attribute: If you need responsive images, make sure to include the srcset attribute in your <img> element.

2. Removing the sizes Attribute (if not necessary): If responsive images are not required and you’re not using srcset, simply remove the sizes attribute.

Example

Incorrect Markup:

<img src="image.jpg" sizes="(max-width: 600px) 480px, 800px" alt="Example Image">

Correct Markup with srcset:

<img src="image.jpg" 
     srcset="image-480w.jpg 480w, image-800w.jpg 800w" 
     sizes="(max-width: 600px) 480px, 800px" 
     alt="Example Image">

In this correct example, the srcset attribute provides two different images (image-480w.jpg and image-800w.jpg) and their corresponding widths (480w and 800w). The sizes attribute tells the browser to use the 480 pixels wide image if the viewport is 600 pixels or less, otherwise, it will use the full 800 pixels.

Correct Markup without sizes and srcset:

<img src="image.jpg" alt="Example Image">

If you don’t need responsive images, simply remove the sizes attribute to fix the issue.

Summary

Ensure that whenever you use the sizes attribute, you also include a srcset attribute. This makes sure that the browser can effectively make decisions about which image size to load in different scenarios.

A srcset attribute with width descriptors requires a sizes attribute on the img element.

When you use width descriptors (e.g., 400w, 800w) in the srcset attribute, the browser needs the sizes attribute to correctly select the appropriate image source based on the layout size in the viewport. Without sizes, the HTML is invalid, and the browser cannot resolve how large the image will be displayed.

Explanation

The srcset attribute allows you to provide multiple image sources for different screen conditions. There are two types of descriptors in srcset: width descriptors (e.g., 400w) and pixel density descriptors (e.g., 2x). When using width descriptors, you must include a sizes attribute to describe the expected display width of the image in CSS pixels. This helps browsers pick the best matching source.

Correct Usage Example

<img
  src="image-400.jpg"
  srcset="image-400.jpg 400w, image-800.jpg 800w"
  sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px"
  alt="Responsive example">

Incorrect Usage Example

<img
  src="image-400.jpg"
  srcset="image-400.jpg 400w, image-800.jpg 800w"
  alt="Responsive example">

(Missing sizes attribute)

Explanation of the correct example:

• The srcset attribute lists two images with their respective pixel widths.
• The sizes attribute tells the browser to use 100vw (100% of the viewport width) if the viewport is 600px wide or less, and otherwise use 600px as the display width.