Bad value “icon” for attribute “role” on element “span”.

The WAI-ARIA specification defines a specific set of role values that assistive technologies like screen readers understand. These include roles such as button, checkbox, alert, dialog, img, navigation, banner, and many others. The value "icon" is not among them. When a browser or assistive technology encounters an unrecognized role, it cannot determine the element’s purpose, which defeats the goal of using ARIA in the first place.

This is primarily an accessibility problem. Screen readers rely on valid ARIA roles to communicate the nature of elements to users. An invalid role like "icon" is either ignored or causes unpredictable behavior, leaving users of assistive technologies without the context they need. It’s also a standards compliance issue — the W3C validator flags this because the HTML specification requires role values to match roles defined in the ARIA specification.

The fix depends on the purpose of the element:

• Decorative icons (that don’t convey information): Remove the role attribute entirely, or use aria-hidden="true" to explicitly hide the element from the accessibility tree.
• Meaningful icons (that convey information visually): Use role="img" along with an aria-label to provide a text alternative.
• Icons inside interactive elements: Hide the icon with aria-hidden="true" and ensure the parent interactive element has an accessible name through visible text or an aria-label.

Examples

❌ Invalid: Using the non-existent "icon" role

<span class="icon" role="icon"></span>

This triggers the validation error because "icon" is not a valid ARIA role.

✅ Fixed: Decorative icon with no role

If the icon is purely decorative and doesn’t convey any meaning (e.g., it’s next to text that already describes the action), simply remove the role attribute. Adding aria-hidden="true" ensures screen readers skip over it completely.

<span class="icon" aria-hidden="true"></span>

✅ Fixed: Meaningful icon using role="img"

If the icon conveys meaningful information that isn’t available through surrounding text, use role="img" and provide a descriptive aria-label:

<span class="icon-warning" role="img" aria-label="Warning"></span>

This tells assistive technologies that the element represents an image and gives it an accessible name of “Warning.”

✅ Fixed: Icon inside a button

When an icon is placed inside an interactive element like a button, hide the icon from the accessibility tree and let the button’s text or label provide the meaning:

<button>
  <span class="icon-save" aria-hidden="true"></span>
  Save
</button>

If the button has no visible text (an icon-only button), provide an aria-label on the button itself:

<button aria-label="Save">
  <span class="icon-save" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</button>

✅ Fixed: Icon using an <img> element instead

If you’re using an actual image file for the icon, consider using a semantic <img> element, which has a built-in img role:

<img src="icon-alert.svg" alt="Alert" class="icon">

For decorative image icons, use an empty alt attribute:

<img src="icon-decorative.svg" alt="" class="icon">

Learn more:

MDN Reference

MDN: WAI-ARIA Roles

→